In short
A company that receives a demand notice under section 8 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 has ten days from receipt to do one of two things: show the creditor that a dispute already exists, or prove that the debt has been paid. After the ten days an unpaid operational creditor can apply to the National Company Law Tribunal. The Code applies only where the default is ₹1 crore or more (sections 4, 8 and 9).
The next 48 hours
- 1Note the day the demand notice or invoice was received.
- 2Check the papers for any dispute raised before, and any suit or arbitration filed before the notice.
- 3Check whether the debt was paid, and gather the proof.
The deadlines
- Ten days from receipt of the demand notice to bring to the creditor's notice a dispute (or a record of a suit or arbitration filed before the notice), or payment of the debt.
- The minimum amount of default for an insolvency application is ₹1 crore.
The routes
- Payment. Paying the debt, and sending proof of payment to the creditor.
- Raising a dispute. Bringing to the creditor's notice the existence of a dispute, or a suit or arbitration filed before the notice, within the ten days.
- Defending an application. If the creditor applies to the Tribunal after the ten days, the record of the dispute or of payment decides the response (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, sections 8 and 9).
How it usually runs
A demand notice under section 8 is the step an unpaid supplier, or other operational creditor, must take before asking the National Company Law Tribunal to begin a company's insolvency. It is addressed to the company. The Code applies only where the default is ₹1 crore or more.
The reply decides what happens next. If the creditor has received notice of a dispute, the Tribunal is to reject the application (section 9(5)(ii)(d)). The Code speaks of an existing dispute, and of a suit or arbitration filed before the notice was received, so a dispute recorded in earlier emails counts for more than one raised for the first time in the reply.
What the law says
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 4
- The Code applies to a company only where the default is ₹1 crore or more.
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 8(2)
- A company has ten days from receipt of a demand notice to show an existing dispute, or proof of payment.
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 5(6)
- A dispute includes a suit or arbitration about the amount of the debt, the quality of goods or service, or a breach of representation or warranty.
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 9(1)
- After the ten days, an unpaid operational creditor who has received no notice of a dispute may apply to the National Company Law Tribunal.
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 9(5)(ii)(d)
- The Tribunal is to reject an operational creditor's application where the creditor has received a notice of dispute, or a dispute is on record with the information utility.
What to avoid
- Letting the ten days pass while negotiating by telephone.
- Replying without the earlier correspondence that shows the dispute.
- Treating it as an ordinary recovery letter.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- When did the notice reach the registered office?
- Is the invoice amount accepted, in whole or in part?
- What did the company write about quality, quantity or amount before the notice?
- Is any suit or arbitration already pending?