What it is
A demand notice, or a copy of an invoice, demanding payment of an operational debt on which there has been a default.
Who sends it. An operational creditor: a person owed money for goods, services or employment.
The time that matters
Ten days from receipt, to bring to the creditor's notice either the existence of a dispute, or proof that the debt has been paid.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 8(2)
What to do first
- 1Note the date the notice was delivered. The ten days are short and run from that date.
- 2Check the amount. If the default is below ₹1 crore, say so in the reply.
- 3Look for a dispute that already exists: emails rejecting the goods, a debit note, a notice of your own, a pending suit or arbitration. It has to pre-date the demand notice.
- 4If the amount is owed and can be paid, pay it and keep the bank record.
- 5Reply in writing within the ten days, with the documents attached.
What the law says
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 4, as amended by notification S.O. 1205(E) of 24 March 2020
- The Code applies to a company only where the default is ₹1 crore or more.
- Section 8(2)(a)
- Within ten days the company may show a dispute, including a record of a suit or arbitration filed before it received the notice.
- Section 5(6)
- A "dispute" includes a suit or arbitration about the existence of the amount of the debt, the quality of the goods or service, or a breach of a representation or warranty.
- Section 8(2)(b)
- Or the company may show payment, by an attested copy of the record of the electronic transfer, or of the record that the creditor has encashed a cheque.
- Section 9(1)
- If ten days pass with neither payment nor notice of a dispute, the creditor may apply to the National Company Law Tribunal to start a corporate insolvency resolution process.
What a reply should do
- State the date the notice was received.
- Set out the dispute, with the earlier correspondence that shows it existed before the notice.
- Give the particulars of any suit or arbitration already filed.
- Or attach proof of payment.
- Keep proof of how and when the reply was sent.
If nothing is done
If nothing is said within ten days, the creditor may file an application before the Tribunal. A dispute raised for the first time after that is far harder to rely on.