In short
A bad outcome is not by itself negligence: a claim has to show that the care fell below the standard expected and that this caused the harm. Ask for the complete medical records in writing first. The usual forum is the Consumer Commission, and a complaint must be filed within two years of the cause of action unless sufficient cause for delay is shown (Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 69).
The next 48 hours
- 1Ask for the complete medical records, in writing, and keep the request.
- 2Write down the sequence of events and the names of those involved, while it is fresh.
- 3Keep every bill and receipt.
The deadlines
- A consumer complaint is not admitted unless it is filed within two years from the cause of action, unless sufficient cause is shown.
The routes
- A Consumer Commission. A complaint for deficiency in service. Which Commission depends on the value paid.
- A medical opinion. An independent medical opinion on the records, to see whether the care fell below what is expected and whether that caused the harm.
- Other routes. A criminal complaint, and a complaint to the medical council, are separate routes with their own tests.
How it usually runs
A bad outcome is not by itself negligence. A claim has to show that the care fell below the standard expected of a reasonably competent practitioner, and that this caused the harm. That is decided on the records, and usually on a medical opinion, which is why obtaining the complete record comes first.
The usual forum is the Consumer Commission, chosen by the amount paid for the treatment. A complaint to the medical council concerns the doctor's professional conduct. A criminal complaint is judged by a stricter test. Neither of those two awards compensation.
What the law says
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 39(1)
- A Commission may order the defect to be removed, the goods to be replaced, the price or charges to be returned with interest, and compensation for loss or injury caused by negligence.
- Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, rules 3 to 5
- The Commission is chosen by the amount paid: up to ₹50 lakh, the District Commission; above that and up to ₹2 crore, the State Commission; above ₹2 crore, the National Commission.
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 69
- A complaint is not admitted unless it is filed within two years of the cause of action. A later complaint can be accepted for sufficient cause, with reasons recorded.
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 38(2)(a)
- Once a complaint is admitted, the opposite party has 30 days to give its version, which the Commission can extend by up to 15 days.
What to avoid
- Posting allegations about the doctor online before the records have been reviewed.
- Signing papers at discharge that you have not read.
- Delaying the request for the records.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- What were the dates of admission, procedure and discharge?
- What was the patient told about the risks, and what was signed?
- What went wrong, and when was it first noticed?
- Do you have the full record, and a second opinion?