A bad outcome is not, by itself, negligence. Medicine carries risk, and a patient can be harmed even when everything was done properly. A claim succeeds only when the records show that the care fell below the standard expected, and that this caused the harm.
What has to be shown
Courts and Commissions look for three things.
- A duty of care. The hospital or doctor undertook to treat the patient.
- A breach. The care given fell below what a reasonably competent practitioner in that field would have given, judged by the practice of the time.
- Causation. That failure caused the injury or death, and it was not simply the course of the illness.
An error of judgment in choosing between two accepted lines of treatment is not negligence. A failure to do what no reasonable practitioner would have omitted is.
The records decide the case
Almost every medical negligence case is decided on the hospital’s own papers.
- Ask in writing for the complete medical record: admission notes, consent forms, nursing charts, operation notes, drug charts, investigation reports and the discharge or death summary.
- Keep every bill and prescription.
- Write down your own account of what happened, with dates and times, while it is fresh.
An independent medical opinion
Before filing, the records should be read by a doctor in the same speciality who has no connection with the hospital. Without such an opinion a complaint is hard to prove, and it is the first thing the other side will ask for.
The routes
A consumer complaint. Medical treatment that is paid for is a service, and a failure in it is a deficiency. The Commission is chosen by the amount paid for the treatment: up to ₹50 lakh, the District Commission; above that and up to ₹2 crore, the State Commission; above ₹2 crore, the National Commission (Jurisdiction Rules, 2021). The complaint must be filed within two years of the cause of action (Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 69).
A complaint to the medical council. This concerns the doctor’s professional conduct. It does not award compensation.
A criminal complaint. This is reserved for gross negligence, and the test is much stricter than in a civil or consumer case.
These are separate routes. They do not depend on one another, and each has its own standard.
What compensation covers
Where negligence is proved, compensation is assessed on the cost of treatment, loss of income, the cost of future care, and the pain and loss suffered.
Timing
Two years is not long when records have to be obtained and an opinion taken. Ask for the records at once.
General information, not legal advice.
Sources
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019Act 35 of 2019, ss. 35, 38, 41, 51, 67, 69Official source
- Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021G.S.R. 912(E), 30 December 2021, rr. 3 to 5Official source
Comments
Questions about the law are welcome. Comments cannot be answered as advice on a particular case, and a first comment is shown once it is approved.
No comments yet.
Please complete the check above and fill in every field.Thank you. Your comment will appear once it has been approved.Thank you. Your comment has been posted.Sorry, your comment could not be sent. Please try again.