What the offence is
The complaint stands on a chain of dates: presentation of the cheque, the notice, the fifteen days, and the filing. A break in the chain ends the complaint. If the chain holds, the defence is on the debt itself.
What the law says
- Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, section 138 and its proviso
- The offence arises only if the cheque was given for a legally enforceable debt or liability, was presented in time, the payee demanded the amount in writing within 30 days of the bank's intimation, and the drawer did not pay within 15 days of receiving that notice.
- Section 139
- The law presumes, unless the contrary is proved, that the holder received the cheque for the discharge of a debt or liability.
- Section 140
- It is no defence that the drawer had no reason to believe, when issuing the cheque, that it would be dishonoured.
- Section 142(1)(b) and (2)(a)
- The complaint must be filed within one month of the cause of action, in the court within whose jurisdiction the payee's bank branch is situated where the cheque was delivered for collection through an account.
- Section 143A
- The court may order interim compensation of up to 20% of the cheque amount once the accused pleads not guilty. If the accused is acquitted, the complainant has to repay it with interest.
- Section 147
- The offence can be compounded at any stage.
- Section 148
- In an appeal against conviction, the appellate court may order the appellant to deposit at least 20% of the fine or compensation awarded.
What the case turns on
- Was the notice sent within 30 days of the bank's memo, and when was it received?
- Was the complaint filed within one month after the fifteen days ended?
- Was there a debt on the date of the cheque, and for what amount?
- Was the cheque given as security, or for a liability that never arose?
- For a company's cheque: was this person in charge of its business at the time?
The stages
- 1The notice, and a written reply within the fifteen days.
- 2The summons, and appearance or exemption from it.
- 3The trial, with cross-examination of the complainant on the debt.
- 4Settlement at any stage; or appeal against conviction and sentence, and revision.