- 20%The most a trial court can order as interim compensation (s. 143A(2))
- 60 daysTo pay it, plus up to 30 more for sufficient cause (s. 143A(3))
- 20%The least an appellate court can order deposited on appeal (s. 148(1))
Once a cheque case is in court, two provisions can make the accused pay part of the money long before the case ends. Section 143A lets the trial court order interim compensation of up to 20% of the cheque amount. Section 148 lets the appellate court order a deposit of at least 20% of the fine or compensation when a convicted drawer appeals.
Interim compensation during the trial
Section 143A of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 allows the court trying a Section 138 case to order the drawer of the cheque to pay interim compensation to the complainant. It can do so:
- in a summary trial or a summons case, once the accused pleads not guilty; and
- in any other case, once the charge is framed.
The power is discretionary: the section says the court “may” order it. It is not ordered as a matter of course.
How much. Not more than 20% of the cheque amount (section 143A(2)).
By when. Within 60 days of the order, or within a further period of up to 30 days that the court may allow if the drawer shows sufficient cause (section 143A(3)).
If it is not paid. It can be recovered as if it were a fine (section 143A(5)).
If the drawer is acquitted. The court directs the complainant to repay it, with interest at the Reserve Bank’s bank rate prevailing at the start of that financial year, within 60 days, or a further 30 days on sufficient cause (section 143A(4)).
If the drawer is convicted. The fine, or the compensation the court awards, is reduced by what was already paid as interim compensation (section 143A(6)).
The deposit on appeal
When a drawer convicted under Section 138 appeals, the appellate court may order the appellant to deposit a sum of at least 20% of the fine or compensation awarded by the trial court (section 148(1)). This is in addition to any interim compensation already paid under section 143A.
- Time to deposit: 60 days from the order, or a further period of up to 30 days on sufficient cause (section 148(2)).
- Release to the complainant: the appellate court may release the deposit to the complainant while the appeal is pending (section 148(3)).
- If the appellant is acquitted: the complainant repays what was released, with interest at the bank rate, within 60 days, or a further 30 on sufficient cause (proviso to section 148(3)).
What this means for each side
If you are the complainant. Once the accused pleads not guilty, or the charge is framed, an application for interim compensation can be made. Keep in mind that it must be repaid with interest if the accused is acquitted.
If you are the accused. Expect the question to arise early in the trial. An order under section 143A can be answered on its facts: the court is choosing whether to order anything at all, and how much up to the 20% ceiling. If you are convicted and appeal, plan for a deposit of at least 20% of what the trial court awarded, payable within 60 days of the appellate court’s order.
How fast a cheque trial is meant to run
Cheque cases are tried by a Judicial Magistrate of the first class or a Metropolitan Magistrate, ordinarily in a summary manner, and an endeavour is to be made to conclude the trial within six months of the complaint (section 143(1) and (3)). In practice many take longer, which is why the interim payment provisions matter.
General information, not legal advice.
Sources
- Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, sections 143, 143A and 148Act 26 of 1881, ss. 143, 143A, 148 (ss. 143A and 148 inserted by Act 20 of 2018, w.e.f. 1 September 2018)Official source
Comments
Questions about the law are welcome. Comments cannot be answered as advice on a particular case, and a first comment is shown once it is approved.
No comments yet.
Please complete the check above and fill in every field.Thank you. Your comment will appear once it has been approved.Thank you. Your comment has been posted.Sorry, your comment could not be sent. Please try again.