In short
When ownership of a property, or a document in its chain of title, is disputed, collect the full chain of documents and sign nothing new until it has been checked. The remedy is a suit for a declaration of title (Specific Relief Act, 1963, section 34), which must be filed within three years of the right to sue first accruing, and a suit for possession on title within twelve years (Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Articles 58 and 65).
The next 48 hours
- 1Collect the full chain of title, from the earliest paper you have.
- 2Check the registration and mutation records.
- 3Do not sign or register any new document about the property until the chain has been checked.
The deadlines
- Three years for a declaration, from when the right to sue first accrues; twelve years for possession based on title (Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Articles 58 and 65).
The routes
- A title search and review. A review of the papers to find the gap or defect.
- A suit for declaration. A suit for a declaration of title, with an injunction.
- A challenge to a document. A suit to cancel a document said to be void or forged.
How it usually runs
Title is proved by an unbroken chain of documents from a lawful owner to you: sale deeds, gift deeds, wills, partition deeds, and the revenue and municipal records that follow them. A dispute usually attacks one link: a forged deed, a sale by someone with no authority, an earlier agreement, or a claim by an heir who was left out.
Entries in municipal or revenue records support possession and liability for tax; they are not, by themselves, proof of ownership. The remedy is a suit for a declaration of title, with possession or an injunction where needed (Specific Relief Act, 1963, section 34), and a suit to cancel a document said to be void or forged (section 31).
What the law says
- Specific Relief Act, 1963, section 34
- A person entitled to a right in property may sue for a declaration against anyone who denies it. The court will not grant a bare declaration where further relief could have been asked for and was not.
- Specific Relief Act, 1963, section 31
- A person against whom a written instrument is void or voidable, and who fears serious injury if it is left outstanding, may sue to have it cancelled.
- Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Article 58
- A suit for a declaration must be filed within three years of the right to sue first accruing.
- Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Article 65
- A suit for possession based on title must be filed within twelve years of the other side's possession becoming adverse.
- Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Order XXXIX Rule 1
- A temporary injunction may be granted where property in dispute is in danger of being wasted, damaged or alienated, or where the defendant threatens to dispossess the plaintiff.
What to avoid
- Buying, selling or mortgaging while the dispute is live without disclosing it.
- Relying on a chain of powers of attorney without having it checked.
- Letting three years pass after you learn of the rival document.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- What is the chain of documents, from the earliest you hold?
- Which document or claim is disputed, and by whom?
- Who is in possession?
- When did you first learn of the rival claim?