In short
When a government authority passes an order against your business, read it first for the provision it was made under, the appeal it allows and the time for that appeal. Where the statute gives an appeal, it is usually expected to be used first. A writ petition to the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution is the route where the order was made without jurisdiction or without a hearing. The Constitution fixes no period for it, but unexplained delay is a reason for which a court may decline to hear it.
The next 48 hours
- 1Read the order and note its date and the authority that passed it.
- 2Check whether it says an appeal or review lies, and to whom.
- 3If a hearing, deadline or limitation date is within 48 hours, call or WhatsApp rather than use the form.
The deadlines
- The period for an appeal is the one stated in the order, or in the Act under which it was passed. Find it first.
- The Constitution fixes no period for a writ petition (Article 226). Unexplained delay is a reason for which a court may decline to hear it.
The routes
- The statutory appeal. An appeal to the authority or tribunal the Act names.
- A writ petition. A petition to the High Court under Article 226, where the order is without jurisdiction or breaches natural justice.
- A representation. A written representation to the authority, with the grounds.
How it usually runs
An order of a government authority can be challenged on a limited set of grounds: that the authority had no power to make it, that no notice or hearing was given, that it gives no reasons, that it ignored relevant material, or that it is arbitrary or out of proportion. A court does not usually decide the merits afresh, as an appeal would.
Where the statute gives an appeal, the High Court usually expects it to be used first, unless the order was made without jurisdiction or without a hearing. So the first reading of the order is for three things: the provision it was made under, the appeal it allows, and the time for that appeal. A stay of the order is a separate request and has to be justified on its own.
What the law says
- Constitution of India, Article 226(1)
- Every High Court may issue directions, orders or writs to any authority or Government for the enforcement of fundamental rights and for any other purpose.
- Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, section 80(1) and (2)
- A suit against the Government or a public officer cannot be filed until two months after written notice, unless the court gives leave because the relief is urgent.
What to avoid
- Carrying on in breach of a closure or stop order while challenging it.
- Missing the appeal period while writing representations.
- Filing a writ petition and an appeal against the same order without disclosing both.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- What is the date of the order, and when did you receive it?
- Was there a show-cause notice, did you reply, and were you heard?
- Under which law and provision was it passed?
- What is its immediate effect on the business?