In short
A government employee served with a charge memorandum should note the date to reply, ask for the documents the charges rely on, and take part in the inquiry. An appeal against a penalty lies to the authority named in the service rules. An application to the Central Administrative Tribunal must be made within one year of the final order, and ordinarily only after the remedies under the service rules have been used (Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, sections 20 and 21).
The next 48 hours
- 1Read the memorandum of charges and note the date to reply.
- 2Ask for the documents the charges rely on.
- 3Do not reply in your own words before the charges have been read.
The deadlines
- The time given in the charge memorandum to reply.
- The service rules fix the period for a departmental appeal. An application to the Central Administrative Tribunal must be made within one year of the final order (Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, section 21(1)(a)).
The routes
- A reply and a defence. A reply to the charges, and participation in the inquiry.
- An appeal. Against the penalty, to the appellate authority named in the service rules, within the time they fix.
- The Tribunal or High Court. The Central Administrative Tribunal for central employees, or a writ petition, as the case requires.
How it usually runs
A departmental inquiry follows a sequence set by the service rules: a memorandum with the articles of charge and the lists of documents and witnesses, a written reply, an inquiry officer who hears evidence, a report, a chance to represent against the report, and the order of the disciplinary authority.
Suspension is not a punishment. It is an interim step, with a subsistence allowance. The points most often argued later are whether the documents relied on were supplied, whether the witnesses could be cross-examined, and whether the penalty is in proportion. Those points have to be raised in the inquiry itself first; a Tribunal looks at the record.
What the law says
- Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, sections 20(1) and 21(1)(a)
- The Central Administrative Tribunal does not ordinarily admit an application unless the remedies under the service rules have been used, and the application must be made within one year of the final order.
- Constitution of India, Article 226(1)
- Every High Court may issue directions, orders or writs to any authority or Government for the enforcement of fundamental rights and for any other purpose.
What to avoid
- Admitting or denying the charges in a hurried reply, before the documents have been supplied.
- Boycotting the inquiry.
- Approaching the witnesses.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- What is the service and the post, and which rules apply?
- What is the date of the charge memorandum, and when is the reply due?
- Have you been suspended, since when, and is the subsistence allowance being paid?
- Is there a connected criminal case?