In short
If goods delivered under a contract are defective, keep them as they are, photograph them, and give the seller written notice of the defect within the period the contract sets. The remedies are repair or replacement, a reduction in price, or rejection and a claim for the price and the loss. A suit for compensation must be filed within three years of the breach (Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Article 55).
The next 48 hours
- 1Photograph and record the goods, and keep them as they are.
- 2Give written notice of the defect, as the contract requires.
- 3Note the dates of delivery and of the notice.
The deadlines
- The period for notice of a defect or rejection in the contract.
- A suit for compensation for breach of contract must be filed within three years of the breach (Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Article 55).
The routes
- A notice of defect. A written notice that lists the defects and asks for a repair, replacement or refund.
- A claim. Arbitration under the contract, or a commercial suit for the price and losses.
- A consumer complaint. Where the buyer is a consumer, a complaint to the Consumer Commission.
How it usually runs
When goods delivered under a contract are defective, the buyer's position depends on what the contract promised by way of specification, sample or warranty, on how quickly the defect was notified, and on whether the goods were kept and used.
Put the defect in writing at once, with photographs and, where possible, a joint inspection or an independent report. The remedies are repair or replacement under the contract, a reduction in price, or rejection and a claim for the price and the loss. A written and timely objection also counts as a dispute if the seller later sends an insolvency demand notice (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 5(6)).
What the law says
- Indian Contract Act, 1872, section 73
- A party who suffers by a breach of contract is entitled to compensation for the loss that naturally arose from it in the usual course of things, or that both parties knew was likely when they made the contract.
- Limitation Act, 1963, Schedule, Article 55
- A suit for compensation for breach of contract must be filed within three years of the breach.
- Commercial Courts Act, 2015, sections 2(1)(i) and 12A
- A commercial suit of ₹3 lakh or more that does not seek urgent interim relief cannot be filed until pre-institution mediation has been tried. The mediation is to finish in three months, extendable by two, and that time is left out of limitation.
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, section 5(6)
- A dispute includes a suit or arbitration about the amount of the debt, the quality of goods or service, or a breach of representation or warranty.
What to avoid
- Using or reselling the goods after calling them defective, with nothing recorded.
- Holding back payment in silence.
- Returning the goods without a delivery record.
The papers to gather
What an advocate will ask first
- What was ordered, and against what specification?
- When were the goods delivered, and when was the defect found and notified?
- Where are the goods now?
- How much has been paid, and what is the loss?