- 30 daysFor the other side to appoint or agree, before a court can be asked
- 6 monthsFor the statements of claim and defence
- 12 monthsFor the award, from the end of pleadings (domestic)
- 3 monthsTo challenge the award, plus 30 days for sufficient cause
An arbitration is a private trial that the parties agreed to in their contract. It starts when the other side receives a request to refer the dispute to arbitration.1 If the two sides cannot agree on the arbitrator within 30 days, either can ask the High Court to appoint one.1 The statements of claim and defence must be completed within six months of the arbitrator’s appointment, and in a domestic arbitration the award is due within twelve months after that.1 An award can be set aside only on the grounds in section 34, on an application made within three months of receiving it.1 Once that time has passed, the award is enforced as if it were a decree of a court.1
This guide follows an arbitration from the clause in the contract to the money, for both sides: the party bringing the claim and the party defending it. It covers arbitrations seated in India under Part I of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, with the procedure as it applies in Delhi.
The whole route on one screen
The stages in order. Each has its own chapter below.
| # | Stage | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A written arbitration agreement | Section 71 |
| 2 | The notice invoking arbitration | Section 21: proceedings begin when the respondent receives it1 |
| 3 | Appointing the tribunal, by agreement or by the court | Sections 10 and 111 |
| 4 | Interim relief, from the court or the tribunal | Sections 9 and 171 |
| 5 | Objections to jurisdiction | Section 16: raised by the statement of defence1 |
| 6 | Statements of claim and defence | Section 23: within six months of appointment1 |
| 7 | Hearing and evidence | Sections 18 to 251 |
| 8 | The award | Sections 29A and 31: twelve months from pleadings (domestic)1 |
| 9 | A challenge to the award | Section 34: three months, plus 30 days at most1 |
| 10 | Enforcement | Section 36: as a decree1 |
| 11 | Appeal | Section 37: one appeal, no second appeal1 |
The arbitration agreement
Arbitration rests on an agreement. The Act defines it as an agreement to submit to arbitration all or certain disputes that have arisen, or may arise, between the parties in respect of a defined legal relationship, whether contractual or not.1 It may be a clause in a contract or a separate agreement.1
It must be in writing. An agreement is in writing if it is contained in:1
- a document signed by the parties;
- an exchange of letters, telex, telegrams or other means of telecommunication, including electronic communication, that provides a record of the agreement; or
- an exchange of statements of claim and defence in which one party alleges the agreement and the other does not deny it.
A contract that refers to another document containing an arbitration clause makes that clause part of the contract, if the contract is in writing and the reference is such as to make the clause part of it.1 This is how a clause in standard terms, or in a parent agreement, is often brought into a purchase order or work order.
The clause survives the contract. An arbitration clause is treated as an agreement independent of the other terms of the contract. A tribunal’s decision that the contract is void does not by itself make the clause invalid.1
Some disputes cannot go to arbitration. Part I of the Act does not affect any other law under which certain disputes may not be submitted to arbitration.1 A court can set aside an award if the subject matter was not capable of settlement by arbitration.1
Arbitration under another statute. Some laws send disputes to arbitration whatever the contract says. Part I then applies, largely as if there were an arbitration agreement.1 The most common example in commercial practice is a delayed-payment reference by a micro or small supplier to the Facilitation Council; see the MSME delayed payments guide.
If a suit is filed despite the clause
A party sued in court on a matter covered by an arbitration clause can apply to the court to refer the parties to arbitration. The application must be made no later than the date of submitting its first statement on the substance of the dispute.1 The court must then refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds that, prima facie, no valid arbitration agreement exists.1
The application must be filed with the original arbitration agreement or a certified copy. If the other side holds the original, the applicant may file a copy with a request that the court call for the original.1 While the application is pending, an arbitration may still be started or continued and an award made.1
For the defendant, timing is everything: a written statement on the merits filed before the application can cost the right to arbitrate. An order refusing to refer the parties to arbitration can be appealed.1
Starting the arbitration: the notice
Unless the parties agreed otherwise, the arbitral proceedings on a dispute commence on the date the respondent receives a request to refer that dispute to arbitration.1 This notice is usually called the notice invoking arbitration.
The date matters for limitation. The Limitation Act, 1963 applies to arbitrations as it applies to proceedings in court, and for that purpose an arbitration is treated as having commenced on the date in section 21.1 A claim that would be time-barred in a suit is time-barred in arbitration. The limitation explainer sets out the periods for money claims.
If the contract says a claim is barred unless arbitration is started within a time it fixes, the court may extend that time where undue hardship would otherwise be caused, on such terms as justice requires.1
A notice should identify the agreement, the dispute, the relief claimed, and the proposed arbitrator or the appointment procedure the clause lays down. What a notice should say on particular facts is a drafting question; the notice invoking arbitration page covers the first steps for a party that receives one.
Appointing the arbitrator
How many. The parties may fix the number of arbitrators. If they have not, the tribunal is a sole arbitrator.1
How they are appointed. The parties may agree on a procedure.1 Where there is no agreed procedure:1
- three arbitrators: each side appoints one, and those two appoint the presiding arbitrator;
- a sole arbitrator: the parties must agree on the person.
When the court steps in. If a party fails to appoint within 30 days of receiving a request, if the two arbitrators fail to agree on the third within 30 days of their appointment, or if the parties fail to agree on a sole arbitrator within 30 days of a request, the appointment is made on a party’s request by the High Court within whose limits the principal civil court under section 2(1)(e) is situated (the Supreme Court, in an international commercial arbitration), or a person or institution it designates.1 The same applies where a party or an institution fails to act under an agreed procedure.1
Three points about a section 11 petition:
- The court looks only at whether an arbitration agreement exists. It confines itself to that examination, notwithstanding any judgment, decree or order of any court.1
- The decision is final. No appeal, including a Letters Patent Appeal, lies against it.1
- Before appointing, the court seeks a written disclosure from the proposed arbitrator, and has regard to any qualifications the agreement requires and to securing an independent and impartial arbitrator.1
The section 11 explainer covers the petition in more detail.
Independence and disclosure. A person approached as an arbitrator must disclose in writing any relationship with or interest in the parties or the subject matter likely to give rise to justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, and anything likely to affect the ability to finish the arbitration within twelve months.1 A person whose relationship with the parties, counsel or the subject matter falls within the Seventh Schedule is ineligible, whatever the earlier agreement says; the parties can waive this only by an express written agreement made after the dispute has arisen.1
Challenging an arbitrator. An arbitrator can be challenged only for justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, or for lacking the qualifications the parties agreed.1 Unless the parties agreed another procedure, the challenge is a written statement of reasons sent to the tribunal within fifteen days of learning of the tribunal’s constitution or of the circumstances.1 If the challenge fails, the tribunal continues and makes its award; the challenging party can then raise the point in an application to set the award aside.1
Interim relief: the court and the tribunal
Both a court and the tribunal can order interim measures to protect the subject of the dispute until it is decided.
From the court, under section 9. A party may apply to the court before the arbitration, during it, or after the award but before it is enforced under section 36.1 The measures available include:1
- preserving, holding in custody or selling goods that are the subject matter of the agreement;
- securing the amount in dispute;
- detaining, preserving or inspecting property, with power to enter land or take samples;
- an interim injunction or the appointment of a receiver;
- any other interim measure of protection that is just and convenient.
Two limits apply. If the court grants a measure before the arbitration has begun, the arbitration must be commenced within 90 days of the order, or such further time as the court fixes.1 And once the tribunal has been constituted, the court will not entertain a section 9 application unless the remedy before the tribunal under section 17 may not be efficacious.1
From the tribunal, under section 17. During the proceedings, the tribunal can order the same kinds of measures, with the same powers a court has for its own proceedings.1 Its order is deemed to be an order of the court for all purposes and is enforceable under the Code of Civil Procedure as if it were.1
Orders granting or refusing interim measures, whether by the court under section 9 or by the tribunal under section 17, can be appealed.1 The section 9 explainer deals with what a court looks for.
Objections to the tribunal’s jurisdiction
The tribunal can rule on its own jurisdiction, including objections to the existence or validity of the arbitration agreement.1 Two time limits matter to a respondent:1
- a plea that the tribunal has no jurisdiction must be raised no later than the statement of defence (having appointed or taken part in appointing an arbitrator does not prevent it);
- a plea that the tribunal is exceeding its authority must be raised as soon as the matter is raised in the proceedings.
The tribunal may admit a later plea if it considers the delay justified.1 If it rejects the plea, it continues and makes its award, and the objection can then be pressed in a section 34 application.1 If it accepts a plea that it lacks jurisdiction, that order can be appealed.1
The pleadings and the hearing
Procedure. The parties must be treated equally and each given a full opportunity to present its case.1 The tribunal is not bound by the Code of Civil Procedure or the Evidence Act; the parties may agree the procedure, and failing that the tribunal decides it, including what evidence is admissible and what weight it carries.1 The parties may agree the place of arbitration; otherwise the tribunal fixes it.1
Claim and defence. The claimant states the facts, the points at issue and the relief sought; the respondent states its defence. Each may file the documents it relies on.1 The respondent may also bring a counterclaim or plead a set-off, which the tribunal decides if it falls within the arbitration agreement.1 The statements of claim and defence must be completed within six months of the date the arbitrator, or all the arbitrators, received written notice of appointment.1
Default. Unless the parties agreed otherwise and no sufficient cause is shown:1
- if the claimant fails to file its statement of claim, the tribunal terminates the proceedings;
- if the respondent fails to file its defence, the tribunal continues, without treating the failure as an admission, and may treat the right to file a defence as forfeited;
- if a party fails to appear or to produce documents, the tribunal may continue and make the award on the evidence before it.
Fast track. The parties may agree in writing, before or when the tribunal is appointed, to a fast track procedure: a decision on written pleadings, documents and submissions, with an oral hearing only if all the parties ask for one or the tribunal considers it necessary to clarify issues. The award is then due within six months of the tribunal entering on the reference.1
The time for the award
In an arbitration other than an international commercial arbitration, the award must be made within twelve months of the completion of pleadings under section 23(4).1 In an international commercial arbitration, the Act asks only for an endeavour to finish within that time.1
- Extension by consent: the parties may extend the time by up to six months.1
- Extension by the court: if the award is not made within the period, the arbitrator’s mandate ends unless the court extends it, before or after the period expires, on a party’s application, for sufficient cause and on terms.1 While an application for extension is pending, the mandate continues.1
- Delay by the tribunal: if the court finds the delay was attributable to the tribunal, it may reduce the arbitrator’s fees by up to five per cent for each month of delay, after hearing the arbitrator.1
- Substitution: when extending time, the court may substitute one or all of the arbitrators; the proceedings continue from the stage reached, on the record already made.1
The court is to endeavour to dispose of an extension application within 60 days of notice to the other side.1 The arbitration timeline tool works out these dates.
The award: form, interest and costs
Form. The award must be in writing and signed by the arbitrators (a majority suffices if the reason for a missing signature is stated). It must give reasons, unless the parties agreed otherwise or it records a settlement, and it must state its date and the place of arbitration. Each party receives a signed copy.1 The tribunal may make an interim award on any matter it could decide finally.1
Interest. Unless the parties agreed otherwise, a money award may include interest, at a rate the tribunal thinks reasonable, for any part of the period from the date the cause of action arose to the date of the award.1 After the award, the sum carries interest at two per cent above the current rate of interest on the date of the award, until payment, unless the award directs otherwise.1
Costs. The tribunal fixes the costs: the arbitrators’ fees, legal fees, any institution’s fees and other expenses.1 The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, but the tribunal may order otherwise for recorded reasons.1
Challenging the award: section 34
The only way to challenge an award in court is an application to set it aside under section 34.1 It is not an appeal: the court does not rehear the case.
The grounds. An award may be set aside only if the applicant establishes, on the record of the tribunal, that:1
- a party was under some incapacity;
- the arbitration agreement is not valid under the governing law;
- the applicant was not given proper notice of the appointment of an arbitrator or of the proceedings, or was otherwise unable to present its case;
- the award deals with a dispute outside the submission to arbitration, or decides matters beyond its scope (only that part is set aside if it can be separated); or
- the composition of the tribunal or the procedure was not in accordance with the parties’ agreement or, failing agreement, with Part I;
or if the court finds that the subject matter was not capable of settlement by arbitration, or that the award conflicts with the public policy of India.1
Public policy, narrowly. An award conflicts with the public policy of India only if it was induced or affected by fraud or corruption (or breached section 75 or 81), contravenes the fundamental policy of Indian law, or conflicts with the most basic notions of morality or justice. The test of fundamental policy does not allow a review on the merits.1
Patent illegality. An award in an arbitration other than an international commercial arbitration may also be set aside for patent illegality appearing on the face of the award, but not merely for an erroneous application of the law or by reappreciating the evidence.1
Time. The application cannot be made after three months from the date the applicant received the award, or from the disposal of a request for correction or interpretation under section 33. The court may allow thirty days more for sufficient cause, “but not thereafter”.1
Notice first. The application may be filed only after a prior notice to the other party, with an affidavit confirming that notice was given. It is to be decided within one year of service of that notice.1
Which court. The “Court” is the principal civil court of original jurisdiction in a district, including a High Court exercising ordinary original civil jurisdiction, that would have had jurisdiction over the subject matter in a suit; in an international commercial arbitration, it is the High Court.1 Where the dispute is a commercial dispute of specified value, applications filed on the original side of a High Court go to its Commercial Division, and those that would lie before a district court go to the Commercial Court.2
The section 34 explainer deals with the grounds and how the courts read them.
Enforcing the award
Once the time for a section 34 application has expired, the award is enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure as if it were a decree of the court.1
Filing a section 34 application does not by itself stop enforcement. The award remains enforceable unless the court grants a stay on a separate application, on such conditions as it thinks fit, for recorded reasons.1 For an award for the payment of money, the court must have regard to the rules on staying a money decree.1 If a prima facie case is made out that the arbitration agreement, the contract or the making of the award was induced or effected by fraud or corruption, the court must stay the award unconditionally pending the challenge.1
Enforcement then follows the ordinary procedure for executing a decree. The enforcing an award explainer sets it out.
Appeals
Appeals lie only from the orders the Act lists:1
- refusing to refer the parties to arbitration under section 8;
- granting or refusing an interim measure under section 9;
- setting aside or refusing to set aside an award under section 34;
- a tribunal’s order accepting a plea that it lacks jurisdiction or exceeds its authority; and
- a tribunal’s order granting or refusing an interim measure under section 17.
The appeal goes to the court authorised to hear appeals from original decrees of the court that passed the order. No second appeal lies, but the right to approach the Supreme Court is not affected.1
Both sides at each stage
| Stage | The claimant | The respondent |
|---|---|---|
| Before starting | Check the clause, the parties to it, and the limitation period for each claim | Preserve every document; check whether the clause covers the dispute |
| The notice | Fixes the date the arbitration begins, and so limitation1 | Respond within the time in the clause; watch the 30 days on appointment1 |
| Appointment | Can go to the High Court after 30 days1 | Disclosure and eligibility of the proposed arbitrator; 15 days to challenge1 |
| Interim relief | Section 9 to secure the amount or preserve the goods; start within 90 days1 | Oppose on the merits; note the appeal under section 371 |
| Pleadings | Claim complete within six months of appointment1 | Jurisdiction objection by the defence; counterclaim or set-off1 |
| Award | Interest and costs claimed in the statement of claim1 | Twelve-month limit; extension only by consent or the court1 |
| Challenge and enforcement | Enforce once three months pass; oppose any stay1 | Section 34 within three months; a separate stay application1 |
Questions people ask
Can I go to court instead, if the contract has an arbitration clause?
Only if the other side does not object in time. If it applies before its first statement on the substance of the dispute, the court must refer the matter to arbitration unless, prima facie, no valid agreement exists.1
The other side will not appoint an arbitrator. What can I do?
After 30 days from your request, you can ask the High Court to appoint one under section 11.1
Does an arbitration stop the limitation clock?
The arbitration is treated as commenced on the date the respondent receives the request to refer the dispute.1 That date, not the date of the first hearing, is the one that counts.
How long does the arbitrator have to decide?
In a domestic arbitration, twelve months from the completion of pleadings, extendable by six months by consent, and further only by the court.1
Can the court change the award?
Section 34 allows the court to set an award aside on the listed grounds; it is not an appeal on the merits, and an award cannot be set aside merely for an erroneous application of the law or by reappreciating the evidence.1
If I challenge the award, does it stop the other side from enforcing it?
No. Only a stay granted on a separate application stops enforcement, usually on conditions.1
What to bring to a first consultation
The contract and every document said to contain or incorporate the arbitration clause; the notice invoking arbitration and any reply; correspondence on the appointment of the arbitrator; the statement of claim or defence, if filed; any interim orders; and, after an award, the signed copy and the date it was received.
Where an advocate comes in
An arbitration is often decided by its first steps: whether the notice was given in time, whether the tribunal was properly constituted, whether interim relief secured the amount, and whether objections were raised when the Act requires. We act for claimants and respondents in arbitrations, in petitions under sections 9 and 11, and in challenges to and enforcement of awards before the Delhi High Court and the commercial courts.
General information, not legal advice.
Sources
- Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, sections 2, 7 to 25, 29A, 29B, 31, 31A, 34, 36, 37 and 43Act 26 of 1996, as amended by Act 3 of 2016 and Act 33 of 2019Official source
- Commercial Courts Act, 2015, section 10Act 4 of 2016Official source
Comments
Questions about the law are welcome. Comments cannot be answered as advice on a particular case, and a first comment is shown once it is approved.
No comments yet.
Please complete the check above and fill in every field.Thank you. Your comment will appear once it has been approved.Thank you. Your comment has been posted.Sorry, your comment could not be sent. Please try again.